Home page  |  Help  |  Clear
English  |  French
 Search  |  Categories  |  Titles A-Z  |  Countries  |  Compare countries  |  Index  
Full TOC
Expand Document
Expand Chapter
Preferences

close this bookBaseline Assessment of the Nigerian Pharmaceutical Sector (WHO; 2002; 62 pages)
View the documentAcknowledgements
View the documentList of abbreviations
View the documentExecutive summary
Open this folder and view contentsIntroduction
View the documentTHE HEALTH STATUS OF NIGERIANS
View the documentUnder-Five Morbidity and Mortality Rates
Open this folder and view contentsBASIC HEALTH INDICATORS
View the documentStructure of the health system in Nigeria
Open this folder and view contentsDRUG SECTOR ORGANISATION
Open this folder and view contentsINTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY
Open this folder and view contentsSTUDY DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY
Open this folder and view contentsRESULTS AND ANALYSIS ACCESS
Open this folder and view contentsQUALITY AND SAFETY
Open this folder and view contentsINTERPRETATION OF RESULTS
Open this folder and view contentsCONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDED INTERVENTIONS
Open this folder and view contentsANNEX 1
close this folderANNEX 2
View the documentSurvey Forms for Level II Indicators
 

Survey Forms for Level II Indicators

Survey form 1: Public health facility pharmacy and central/district warehouse

 

% of expired drugs

   

Indicator:

Availability of key drug

   

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Key drugs in stock to treat common conditions
[A]

In stock
[B]
Yes=1, No=0

Drugs in stock that have expired
[C]
Yes=1 No=0

ORS

   

Cotrimoxazole

   

Chloroquine or Sulphadoxine/pyrimethamine

   

Iron tablets

   

Folic Acid

   

Mebendazole

   

Chloramphenicol eye ointment/drops

   

Iodine

   

Benzyl/salicylic acid

   

Paracetamol tablets

   

Amoxycillin syrup

   

Vitamin A

   
     
     
     

Total no. of key drugs [A1]=

[B1]=

[C1]=

% in stock in this facility [B2]=

   

% of expired drugs [C2]=

   

Notes:

[A] List of 10-15 key drugs previously identified at national level must be printed before starting the survey. The process is described on page 21. Add the total number of key drugs [A1].

[B] Mark 1 if stock is available (even if only one dosage form is available). Mark 0 if the drug is not physically available. Add the total at the bottom. [B1]

[B2]

[C] For all drugs in stock, check if expired or not. Add all the “Yes” answers [C1]

[C2]


Survey form 2: Private pharmacy

Indicator:

% of expired drugs

   

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Key drugs in stock to treat common conditions
[A]

Drugs in stock that have expired
[B]
Yes=1 No=0

ORS

 

Cotrimoxazole

 

Chloroquine or Sulphadoxine/pyrimethamine

 

Iron tablets

 

Folic Acid

 

Mebendazole

 

Chloramphenicol eye ointment/drops

 

Iodine

 

Benzyl/salicylic acid

 

Paracetamol tablets

 

Amoxycillin syrup

 

Vitamin A

 
   
   
   

Total no. of key drugs[A1]= % of expired drugs [B2]=

[B1]=

Notes:

[A] List of 10-15 key drugs previously identified at national level must be printed before the survey. The process is described on page 21. Add the total number of key drugs[A1].

[B] Check if expired or not. If any of the strengths has an expiry problem the answer for the drug should be “Yes”.

[B1] Add all the “Yes” answers.

[B2]


Survey form 3: Public facility pharmacy/central district warehouse

Indicator:

Stockout duration

   

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Key drugs
[A]

No. of days out of stock
[B]

No. of review
[C]

Equivalent no. of days/year
(D)=B × 365/C

ORS

     

Cotrimoxazole

     

Chloroquine or Sulphadoxine/pyrimethamine

     

Iron tablets

     

Folic Acid

     

Mebendazole

     

Chloramphenicol eye ointment/drops

     

Iodine

     

Benzyl/salicylic acid

     

Paracetamol tablets

     

Amoxycillin syrup

     

Vitamin A

     
       
       
       

[A1]= Total no of key drugs (sum of A)=

 

[D1]=Sum of D
[E] = Average number of stock out days=[D1/A1]

[D1]= [E]=

Notes:

[A] List of 10-15 key drugs previously identified must already be printed in [A]. (see page 21). Review the stock cards of the key essential drugs listed.

[B] Go through the stockcards covering the review period. Add the number of days that each of the key essential drugs are not available or marked “0” on the stockcard. A drug is considered in stock if it or its equivalent is available in either generic or branded form.

Indicate in (B) the total number of days.

[C] The review should cover a six month to one year period. If this is not possible then indicate the number of days covered by the review.

Example:

Key drugs
[A]

No. of days out of stock
[B]

Number of days covered by the review)
[C]

Equivalent no. of days/year
B × 365/C=(D)

Amoxycillin

58

120 days

58 × 365/120= 176

Cotrimoxazole

90

6 months

90 × 365/180=182

Paracetamol

30

1 year

30 × 365/365=30

A1= 3 keydrugs

     

[A1]= Total no of key drugs =3

 

[E]= Average number of stock out days [D1/A1]=

129 days

Survey form 4: Private drug outlet and public health facility pharmacy

Indicator:

Affordability of key drugs (treating pneumonia without hospitalisation)

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Drug/INN

Preparation

Unit price (inj. vial, tablet, or capsule)

No. of units needed to complete treatment

Total cost U$

E/G × 100=

   

Local

U$

     

[A]

[B]

 

[C]

[D]

[E]

[F]

Crystalline penicillin injection

1 mega unit vial

   

20

   

Amoxicillin

125mg/5ml (syrup or suspension).

   

20

   

Cotrimoxazole

(200mg sulfamethoxazole +40mg trimethoprim /5ml (syrup or suspension).

   

10

   
             
             
             

[G]=Lowest government salary in a week/5 working days 1,375 or 11.3 USD

[H]= F with lowest value

Notes:

Get the prices of drugs listed in the above table. Choose the lowest priced product/brand.
Identify other preparations only when necessary or if the above are not available.

If there are other preparations these should be written in columns [A] & [B] before starting the survey.
(see page 21-Identifying drugs to treat children w/ pneumonia as outpatient).

[B] Only one preparation will be used for each drug.

[C] The field worker will indicate the unit price in local currency & in US$

[D] Before starting the field test, check the STG to determine the number of units needed for the duration of treatment. Print this number on the form for each drug listed.

[E] = Total cost of treatment = C x D. Only one drug (antibiotic) should be used to calculate cost of treatment and not a combination of drugs

[F] = % of treatment cost (per drug) to lowest government salary for one week = E/G x 100

[G] = Get the one week equivalent salary from the daily or monthly lowest salary of government worker/public servant

[H] = F with the lowest value will be used as the % treatment cost/salary of the facility.


Survey form 5: Checklist for storage area in public pharmacy/warehouse

Indicator:

Adequate storage

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Checklist

Storage

Pharmacy

 

(check the box if Yes)

Are there locks which are working in the storage area

Ο

Ο

Storage and shelves area are clean (no dust and litter)

Ο

Ο

No evidence of pests seen in the area

Ο

Ο

There is a roof/ceiling

Ο

Ο

There are windows that can be opened or there are air vents

Ο

Ο

No direct sunlight should enter the area, glass window pane painted white, or with curtains/blinds to protect against sunrays

Ο

Ο

Area free from moisture (leaking drains and taps).
Drugs should not be stored directly on the floor

Ο

Ο

There is a separate storage and dispensing area for issuing drugs

Ο

Ο

Drugs are sorted in systematic way (alphabetical, first expiry-first out)

Ο

Ο

There is stock record system

Ο

Ο

There is a cold storage with temperature chart

Ο

Ο

Rating for the facility: [A]+ [B]/2, if only one exists just use [A] or [B] =

[A]=

[B]=

Facility storage

Rating (check)

Equivalent rating for quality of drugs

Poor

0-3

Ο

Quality may be poor

Not adequate

4-5

Ο

Quality may be doubtful

Moderately adequate

6-7

Ο

Acceptable quality

Adequate

8-10

Ο

Acceptable quality

More than adequate

11

Ο

Good quality

Survey form 6: Rational drug use - Prescribing indicator form (public health facility)

Indicator:

average number of drugs % injection use

% antibiotic use

% drugs in EDL

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Seq. Patient No

Type (R/P)

Date of Rx

N° drugs

Antib

Injec.

No. of Drugs on EDL

 

[A]

 

[B]

(0=no, 1= yes)
[C]

(0=no,1=yes)
[D]

[E]

             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             
             

Total

 

B* =

C* =

D* =

E* =

Average

 

B**

     

Percentage

   

C*/No. of cases × 100 =

D*/No. of cases × 100 =

E*/B* × 100 =

Notes:

[A] Select 30 outpatient patient seen within 6 months- one year period from the records (R = retrospective)/those being treated (P = prospective). Sample of cases can be a combination of P and R. (See page 20: Select patient encounters)

[B] Count number of drugs prescribed for each case. (B* = Total no. of drugs)

Count as 1 a drug given in different preparation (ex: paracetamol tablet and injection two brands of similar chemical entity/INN/generic name will be counted as 1 also

[B**] Average No. of drus prescribed = B*/Number of cases

[C] Indicate 0 if no antibiotic is prescribed and 1 if one or more type of antibiotic is given. (C*= Total of cases with antibiotics)

[D] 0 if no injection and 1 if it was given. (D* = Total of cases with injection)

[E] From the number of drug prescribed for the case, count those included in the EDL (E* = total number of drugs listed in EDL)


Survey form 7: Rational drug use - Patient care form (public health facility)

Indicators:

% of drugs dispensed

% of patients who knows how to take drugs

% drugs with adequate label

   

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Seq. N°

Number of drug prescribed [A]

N° of drugs dispensed
[B]

N° of adequately labelled
[C]

Knows dosage *
(0=no, 1= yes) [D]

         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
         

Count

   

All 1=

Total

Total B=

Total C=

 

Average

     

Percentage

% dispensed = Total B/No prescribed × 100=____

% w/adequate level = Total C/Total B × 100 =

% of patient who know = All 1/cases asked × 100 =____

Notes:

[A] Interview 30 patients leaving the dispensing area/pharmacy (See page 21: Prospective sampling)

[B] Check how many drugs (chemical entity/INN/generic) were given to each patient.

[C] Check which are adequately labelled (name of drug, dosage and duration plus any additional criteria specified by country). A drug is adequately labelled only if all criteria are met.

[D] Ask patient if he/she knows how to take the drug. If patient can correctly give the name of all drugs or state what the drugs are for and how they should be taken.

(0) If the patient cannot give the name of even one drugs or state what the drugs are for or does not know how to take one of the drugs given.


Survey form 8: STG at public health facility

Indicators:

Availability of STG for common local conditions

Availability of Essential Drug List (EDL) at the facility

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Standard treatment guidelines available at facility

(Yes/No)

National STG

 

STG for URTI

 

STG for Diarrhoea

 

STG for Pneumonia

 

Malaria

 

Tuberculosis

 

Others:

 

EDL available at the facility

(Yes/No)

National EDL

 

Provincial/District

 

Primary EDL

 

Others:

 

STG is available in this facility

Yes No

EDL is available in this facility

Yes No

Notes:

The facility is considered to have STG if any of the above is available provided the STG was developed by an independent group and the document is not associated to promote pharmaceutical products.

2. Before the survey, the latest most updated version of EDL must be identified. The facility is considered to have EDL if one of the above is available.


Survey form 9: Treatment of diarrhoea, ARI, and pneumonia at public health facility

Indicators:

% tracer case treated using recommended treatment

Facility

____________

Date

____________

Location

____________

Investigator

____________

Notes: Select at random 30 patients (diarrhea, ARI & pneumonia). Choose only single disease encounters. Always write 1 or 0 for all drugs enumerated.
For assessment (level 1, 2) write A/ B/ C/ D/E on the appropriate spaces. Add total.

Diseases/Drug prescribed

Cases (1=yes/ 0=no)

Total yes (1)/ cases × 100

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

 

Diarrhoea in Children

                     

ORS

                     

Antibiotic

                     

Antidiarrheal

                     

Antispasmodic

                     

Other drugs given

                     

Level I assessment (A/B)

                   

A=___/B=___

Level 1 assessment:

 

A = appropriate = (all criteria: ORS 1, antibiotic 0, antidiarrhoeal 0, antispasmodic 0, other drug 0)

B = not appropriate =(one or all criteria: ORS 0, antibiotic 1, antidiarrheal 1, antispasmodic 1, other drug 1)

Non-pneumoni- acute respiratory tract infection (ARI)

Antibiotic prescribed

                     

Level 1 assessment (A/B)

                   

A=___/B=___

Antipyretic/analgesic

                     

Cough and/or cold drugs

                     

Other drugs given

                     

Level 2 assessment (C/D)

                   

C=___/D=___

Level 1 assessment:

Level 2 assessment: only if level 1 is A

A= appropriate(antibiotic 0)

C= appropriate (all criteria: antipyretic/analgesic 1 or 0, cough/cold 1 or 0, other drug 0)

B= not appropriate(antibiotic 1)

D= not appropriate (other drug 1)

Pneumonia

Crystalline Penicillin inj.

                     

Amoxicillin

                     

Cotrimoxazole

                     

Number of other types of antibiotics:

                     

0

                     

1

                     

>1

                     

Level 1 assessment(A/B/C)

                   

A___,B___,C__

Antipyretic/analgesic

                     

Cough and/or cold drugs

                     

Other drugs given

                     

Level 2 assessment(D/E)

                   

D=___/E=__

Level 1 assessment

Level 2 assessment: only if level 1 is A

A = appropriate = (only one: procaine penicillin or amoxicillin or cotrimoxazole is 1, number of other types of antibiotic 0.)
B= not certain = if none of procaine penicillin or amoxicillin or cotrimoxazole was prescribed, then number of other types of antibiotic can be 0 or 1. (the other antibiotic may be appropriate or not)
C = not appropriate = (any combination of procaine penicillin, amoxicillin, cotrimoxazole and other type of antibiotics. It means > 1 type of antibiotic given in the case.

D = appropriate = (all criteria: antipyretic/analgesic 1 or 0, cough/cold 1 or 0, other drug 0)
E= not appropriate (other drugs 1)

Access and use of medicines

Have you or any members of the household been ill in the last two weeks? (exclude hospital admission)
Yes No

Sex and age of person who has been ill

Male
Female
Age: _____ year(s)

What were the person’s symptoms? (mark one or more)

Diarrhoea
Cough
Fever
Others (symptoms or diagnosis)

What was done for the person? (use numbers to indicate the order of actions taken)

____ Consulted traditional healer

____ Sought advice from friend/neighbour/family

____ Consulted public health clinic/hospital

____ Bought medicine without consultation

____ Consulted private health clinic/hospital

____ Used medicine left from another illness

____ Consulted pharmacist

____ Did nothing

____ Consulted drug seller

(If no one was consulted, skip to question 9)

Was medication prescribed?
Yes No

Which medicines were bought?
All Some None

If not all, why not? (mark one or more)

Price was too high

Traditional healer did not have all the medicines

Did not have enough money

Public pharmacy did not have all the medicines

Not able to borrow enough money

Private pharmacy did not have all the medicines

Too many medicines were prescribed

Drug seller did not have all the medicines

Did not believe all the medicines were needed

Already had some of the medicines at home

Started to feel better

Other

No time to get all the medicines

 

How much of the prescribed medicine was taken?
All Some None

What medicines were used? (include traditional medicines)

Amount spent (write 0 if free)

Mark an X through the source as numbered (1 - 9)

 

Local

US$

(1) Traditional healer
(2) Public health centre/hospital
(3) Private health centre/hospital
(4) Public pharmacy
(5) Private pharmacy

(6) Local store/marketplace
(7) Friends/neighbours/family
(8) Medicines already owned
(9) Other

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

     

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

Estimated family weekly income OR total household expenses last week
Local ____________________ US$ ____________________

to previous section

Please provide your feedback English  |  French